Can Electric Cars Really Save the Planet? Debunking the Myth

There is an ongoing debate about the effectiveness of electric cars in addressing environmental concerns. While they are often hailed as a viable solution to reduce CO2 emissions, some experts argue that they do not solve our problems but rather deepen them. In this article, we will critically analyze the limitations of electric cars and explore alternative solutions for a sustainable future. Can Electric Cars Really Save the Planet? Debunking the Myth 


The electrification of passenger vehicles has gained momentum in recent years as a potential solution to combat climate change. However, contrary to popular belief, many professionals in the automotive industry argue that electric cars do not offer a comprehensive solution. Zsolt Horváth and Tamás Ignácz, Hungarian automotive application engineers and construction executives, express their skepticism about the mainstream narrative. According to them, going electric worsens the situation rather than improving it. In this article, we will delve into the criticisms raised by Horváth and Ignácz, examine the challenges associated with electric cars, and explore alternative approaches to tackle environmental issues.

The Environmental Impact of Electric Cars

One of the main criticisms of electric cars is their limited effectiveness in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. While electric vehicles produce zero emissions during operation, the production process itself can be environmentally taxing. Manufacturing an electric car still involves emitting greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, contributing to the carbon footprint. Additionally, the resources required to build a sustainable and efficient electric transportation system can be excessively costly, especially for smaller or emerging countries. This raises questions about the feasibility and scalability of electric cars as a global solution.

EV or Bust: Why Everyone's Going Electric

The Cost and Efficiency Dilemma

Electric cars face significant challenges in terms of cost and efficiency when compared to their internal combustion engine counterparts. The price of electric vehicles remains considerably higher than traditional vehicles, hindering their widespread adoption. Furthermore, the efficiency of electric cars is still far from optimal. Significant improvements are needed to match the performance of non-electric vehicles. The recharging process is time-consuming, and the cost of battery replacement can be excessively high, especially considering their relatively short lifespan. These limitations undermine the practicality and affordability of electric cars for many consumers.

The Energy Demand Conundrum

A critical concern associated with the mass adoption of electric vehicles is the staggering increase in energy demand. Switching all traffic to electric vehicles would require an unimaginable amount of energy, which cannot be produced without further CO2 emissions. This raises questions about the feasibility of relying solely on electric cars to achieve a carbonless future. Additionally, the question arises of who would bear the financial burden of investing in the necessary infrastructure to meet this heightened energy demand. The lack of a clear strategic plan to finance and maintain such a system raises doubts about its viability.

The Geopolitical and Economic Implications

The shift towards electric cars also has geopolitical and economic ramifications. Countries that possess the necessary base materials and energy sources for electric car production are empowered, while others face increased dependency and potential economic disadvantages. This imbalance threatens the European Union’s position and strengthens countries like Russia and China, creating an uneven playing field. This raises concerns about the motives and contradictions of political elites who advocate for electric cars while perpetuating an environmentally unfriendly system.

Beyond Electric Cars: Addressing Other Polluting Sectors

While electric cars dominate the conversation, there are other sectors that contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions. Aircraft, ships, and heavy traffic vehicles are major sources of pollution that need to be addressed alongside the automotive industry. Additionally, anti-environmental energy-producing technologies, such as coal-based thermal power plants, contribute to the overall problem. Moreover, the issue of ocean pollution, exemplified by the 1.5-million-km2 waste island, poses a severe threat to marine ecosystems. These sectors often receive less attention and action compared to electric cars, highlighting the need for a holistic approach to environmental sustainability.

Rethinking the Economic Model

The authors argue that the root cause of our environmental problems lies in the capitalist economic model’s pursuit of infinite growth in a finite system. The constant drive for GDP growth is incompatible with the preservation of the planet and the well-being of its inhabitants. The authors challenge decision-makers to move away from ideological and personal desires and make strategic decisions based on pure logic and mutual benefits. They emphasize the importance of exploring alternative economic systems that prioritize sustainability and are compatible with diverse cultures worldwide.

The evolution of electric vehicles

Prioritizing Railways for Supply Chain Sustainability

To address the CO2 emissions associated with supply chains, the authors propose prioritizing railways as an alternative to the polluting shipping industry. Many materials are still transported by ships, which not only contribute to atmospheric pollution but also harm oceans. By shifting transportation methods and investing in efficient railways, countries can significantly reduce their carbon footprint and promote sustainable supply chain practices.

Exploring Alternative Solutions

In addition to electric cars, the authors suggest exploring alternative solutions to achieve a sustainable future. One such option is hydrogen-based engines for passenger vehicles. Hydrogen fuel cells offer a promising alternative to traditional electric batteries, providing a cleaner and more efficient source of power. Furthermore, alternative methods for clean electricity production should be explored to reduce reliance on fossil fuels. By investing in these alternatives, we can diversify our energy sources and move towards a more sustainable future.

What are the UK's most popular electric cars? | EV Sales UK


While electric cars have been championed as the solution to reduce CO2 emissions, it is essential to critically evaluate their limitations. The environmental impact of manufacturing electric vehicles, the cost and efficiency dilemmas, the energy demand conundrum, and the geopolitical implications all raise valid concerns. It is crucial to address other polluting sectors and reconsider our economic model to achieve meaningful change. By prioritizing railways for supply chain sustainability and exploring alternative solutions such as hydrogen-based engines, we can work towards a more comprehensive and sustainable approach to combat climate change. It is time to broaden the conversation and consider a range of strategies that will truly protect the environment and ensure a prosperous future for all.